Are you interested in pitting Yoast SEO against All in One SEO?
Both Yoast SEO and All in One SEO are the top two widely-used WordPress SEO plugins available today. They are designed to assist in enhancing your website’s visibility on search engines and social media platforms.
In this piece, we’ll juxtapose Yoast SEO and All in One SEO to help you determine the supreme WordPress SEO plugin.
!Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO – Which reigns supreme?
About Our Competitors
Both All in One SEO and Yoast SEO plugins boast dedicated userbases, ranking among the most favored and utilized WordPress plugins to date.
Initially established in 2007 by Michael Torbert and Steve Mortiboy, All in One SEO for WordPress has garnered vast popularity and stands as one of the most downloaded WordPress plugins in history.
Originally introduced as WordPress SEO by Yoast in 2010, Yoast SEO was developed by Joost de Valk. Through consistent enhancements, it swiftly emerged as a key rival to All in One SEO.
Both these plugins are exceptional, offering all essential features required for optimal SEO performance on your WordPress site.
With that being said, let’s compare Yoast SEO and All in One SEO to determine the superior WordPress SEO plugin.
We have categorized our evaluation into the following segments:
- Installation and Configuration
- Everyday SEO Activities
- Indexing and Sitemaps
- Schema.org Compatibility
- Support for Ecommerce
- Supplementary SEO Tools
- Pricing Evaluation
- Conclusion: Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO – The ultimate choice?
Important: Both plugins also offer limited free versions, but we will be scrutinizing their premium editions for a more comprehensive assessment.
Yoast vs AIOSEO: Installation and Setup
Search engine optimization is a specialized discipline that necessitates time and effort to master effectively across websites.
An ideal WordPress SEO plugin should facilitate the process for novices by allowing them to implement basic SEO principles effortlessly.
Let’s assess how these two plugins compare in terms of setting up and configuring basic SEO settings for WordPress websites.
Yoast SEO – Installation and Configuration
To start, you need to install and activate the Yoast SEO plugin. For detailed instructions, refer to our comprehensive guide on installing a WordPress plugin.
Post-activation, users can navigate to the SEO » General page and initiate the configuration wizard under the Dashboard section.
!Commencing Yoast SEO setup wizard
This wizard guides you through the setup process step by step, allowing novices to begin swiftly without feeling overwhelmed by complicated terminology and choices.
!Yoast SEO setup wizard
Yoast SEO is feature-rich, requiring users to go through various options methodically. To simplify this, we have compiled a tutorial on setting up the Yoast SEO plugin in WordPress.
The settings section in Yoast SEO is meticulously organized, with each page containing distinct tabs for respective configurations.
This structure aids users in quickly locating specific options within the settings.
!Yoast SEO settings
On-screen assistance is available on all pages of Yoast SEO settings. By clicking the purple question mark button at the bottom, users can access support documentation.
!On-screen guidance for Yoast SEO settings
With well-ordered settings, a beginner-friendly configuration wizard, and on-screen support options, novices can easily set up Yoast SEO on their WordPress website.
All in One SEO – Installation and Configuration
To begin, you must install and activate the All in One SEO for WordPress plugin. Refer to our step-by-step guide on installing a WordPress plugin for detailed instructions.
Upon activation, the plugin will automatically launch the setup wizard.
!All in One SEO setup wizard
Simply click on the ‘Let’s Get Started’ button to proceed.
Although All in One SEO and Yoast SEO offer similar options, the former’s setup wizard is more concise. It simplifies these options effectively for beginners.
!All in One SEO setup
We provide a detailed guide on properly configuring All in One SEO, walking you through the entire wizard.
Once you have completed the wizard, access the plugin settings by clicking on the All in One SEO » General Settings page.
!All in One SEO settings
The General Settings page is segmented into different categories. Subsequently, distinct pages are available for various features under the General Settings menu in the left column, such as Search Appearance, Sitemaps, Redirects, and more.
A help icon is positioned next to each option for additional assistance. Clicking the icon unveils a brief description of the feature. Furthermore, a help icon is also placed at the top for further guidance.
!All in One SEO assistance options
This setup ensures that beginners comprehend their actions. By completing the wizard alone, most websites are prepared to commence operations and utilize All in One SEO for daily tasks.
Champion: All in One SEO for WordPress
Both plugins present a plethora of options and endeavor to simplify tasks for users. However, we believe that All in One SEO excels slightly over Yoast SEO with its setup wizard.
Daily SEO Duties – Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO
SEO entails continuous efforts, with each new post or page possessing its individual SEO performance. Consequently, you will frequently utilize your SEO plugin to optimize your content for search engines.
For further insights, refer to our guide on enhancing WordPress blog posts for SEO.
Let’s evaluate how our contenders fare in executing daily SEO activities on your WordPress site.
Daily SEO Tasks in Yoast SEO
Yoast SEO features a content analysis tool that aids in optimizing every post or page on your website. Access this tool by clicking the plugin icon situated in the top right corner.
!Yoast SEO content analysis
Right beneath the post editor, the Yoast SEO meta box houses a snippet preview, focus keyword field, and content analysis.
Behold! The Yoast SEO metabox
The Google Preview showcases how the title and description of your site will appear in search engines. Yoast SEO automatically incorporates your post title as the title and excerpt as the description. However, we suggest customizing it by clicking on it.
By inputting the focus keyword in Yoast SEO, the plugin can scrutinize your content targeted at that specific keyword.
The evaluation is displayed in the content analysis section, offering recommendations on enhancing your post’s SEO rating.
You also have the option to toggle to the Schema tab to modify the article’s schema markup configurations.
Behold! Altering the schema markup for a post in Yoast SEO
The final tab on the menu is the social tab. Here, you can designate an article image for Facebook and tailor your Twitter card.
Behold! Social preferences for Yoast SEO
You can neglect the description and title bank since Yoast SEO will employ your primary SEO title and description in the open graph meta tags.
Everyday SEO Errands in All in One SEO
In contrast to Yoast SEO, All in One SEO furnishes a genuine score for your content – labeled as the TruSEO score – which presents a more actionable strategy for optimizing your content.
Simply modify the post or page you wish to optimize. On the editing screen, you’ll notice the All in One SEO button positioned at the top right with the SEO score for that specific post or page. Expanding this panel unveils the content analysis.
Behold! All in One SEO TruSEO score panel
In addition, you receive a score for each of your focus keywords. Clicking on the keyword expands it, offering insights into actions you can take to boost that score.
Behold! Focus keyword score in All in One SEO
Behold! Title and Meta tag settings in AIOSEO
An immensely valuable feature you’ll notice is Dynamic Tags. These tags enable you to incorporate dynamic elements into your SEO title and descriptions, like the current category, year, month, etc.
For example, if your SEO title is ‘Finest Cafes in NYC (2023),’ using the current year tag will automatically update it to 2024 the following year.
This can heighten your click-through rate in WordPress search results, augmenting traffic and ameliorating your SEO rankings.
With All in One SEO, you can also navigate to the Social tab to set images for Facebook or Twitter.
Behold! AIOSEO social settings for posts and pages
Behold! AIOSEO schema settings for posts and pages
Interested in expediting the process of internal linking? Just click on the Link Assistant tab for automatic internal linking recommendations.
All in One SEO also incorporates a Site Analysis feature, offering an overall evaluation of your site’s SEO settings. Furthermore, you can utilize it for comparing your site with rivals using the Competitor Analysis tool.
Victor: All in One SEO
Both plugins simplify the SEO settings’ editing on a post-by-post basis. Nonetheless, All in One SEO bestows a more practical strategy with its TruSEO score and Focus Keyphrase score. The inclusion of dynamic tags in the title and description furnishes it with an advantage over Yoast SEO.
Indexing and Sitemaps – All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO
One of the paramount duties of an SEO plugin is to aid search engines in discovering more of your content.
This is accomplished by generating sitemaps, connecting to webmaster tools, monitoring your site’s SEO, and more.
Let’s delve into how Yoast SEO and All in One SEO approach this category.
Indexing and Sitemaps – Yoast SEO
Yoast SEO automatically produces XML sitemaps for all your post types. It maintains simplicity by lacking a distinct page to view or regulate your XML sitemaps.
Nonetheless, you can toggle XML sitemaps on or off by visiting the SEO » General section and transitioning to the ‘Features’ tab.
Behold! Yoast webmaster tools
Indexing and Sitemaps – All in One SEO
Behold! All in One SEO sitemaps
Behold! Sitemap settings
Youcan activate Video and News sitemaps as plugins in Yoast. Besides, AIOSEO also includes a sitemap feature for RSS.
!All in One SEO extra sitemaps
Champion: All in One SEO
Both extensions provide excellent XML sitemap functionalities. However, All in One SEO lets you have more extensive control over your XML sitemaps.
Schema.org Help – Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO
Schema markup is a specialized form of HTML coding that enables you to inform search engines more details about the content of your site.
For instance, you can indicate that the content is a recipe, blog article, or a product page. This assists search engines in displaying enriched snippets in search outcomes.
!Rich Snippets in search outcomes illustration
Let’s analyze the comparison of All in One SEO and Yoast SEO in this aspect.
Schema Support – Yoast SEO
Yoast SEO automatically appends schema metadata to your WordPress posts and pages. You can view the default settings by navigating to the SEO » Search Appearance page.
!Schema Knowledge Graph
Scroll to the Knowledge Graph & Schema.org section. Here, you can specify if your website is for an individual or an organization. Further, you can input a name and a logo below.
For additional schema choices, you must switch to the Content Types tab. There, you need to scroll to the bottom where you can find the default Schema settings for your content types.
!Site-wide schema settings in Yoast
You can also modify the schema type for individual posts and pages. Simply edit the content and scroll down to the Yoast SEO meta box, then switch to the Schema tab.
!Modifying schema type for a post or page in Yoast SEO
Moreover, you can also add the Yoast Local SEO extension to provide more detailed data about your business.
Schema Support – All in One SEO
Similarly, All in One SEO contains a preset section for site-wide schema.org settings. You can locate it under the All in One SEO » Search Appearance page.
!Knowledge Graph All in One SEO
From this section, you can include details like your organization or individual name, logo, phone number, and contact category such as sales or support.
You can also adjust the default Schema settings for your various content types.
!Default schema settings for post types
You can also set schema settings for each specific post and page using All in One SEO’s Next-Gen Schema Generator.
Simply scroll down on the post editor screen and go to the Schema tab under AIOSEO settings. Then, click on the ‘Generate Schema’ button.
!Modifying schema type for individual items
This action will open the Schema Catalog, where you can select a schema type to integrate into your content with just a few clicks. This includes book schema, recipe schema, software schema, how-to schema, job posting schema, FAQ schema, and more.
!AIOSEO Schema Catalog
The plugin also brings a local SEO extension to enhance your site for local search outcomes.
Champion: All in One SEO
Both plugins possess complete schema.org support. Nevertheless, All in One SEO excels in making these options more visibly accessible, and the expanding Schema Catalog provides a plethora of schema types.
Ecommerce Assistance – Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO
If you operate an online shop, organic traffic translates directly into sales for your business. This emphasizes the importance of eCommerce SEO for your business.
Let’s evaluate the performance of both plugins for eCommerce websites, regardless of whether they utilize WooCommerce or another eCommerce plugin.
Ecommerce Assistance – Yoast SEO
Yoast SEO inherently supports eCommerce sites. For sites employing WooCommerce, Yoast SEO offers a dedicated Yoast WooCommerce SEO plugin.
By default, you can input product titles and descriptions similar to how you manage your posts and pages. Yoast SEO also generates a product category XML sitemap for your store.
Upon installing WooCommerce SEO, you gain the ability to provide additional data for product pages.
Ecommerce Assistance – All in One SEO
All in One SEO for WordPress presents more comprehensive eCommerce support options by default. When you add a product, it correctly identifies it as a Product in schema markup without requiring any manual input.
Furthermore, it enables you to incorporate more eCommerce schema data to aid in the growth of your store. For each product, you can adjust the schema markup and furnish comprehensive details such as brand, colors, manufacturer, and more.
All in One SEO also automatically creates XML sitemaps for your products and product categories.
If you are utilizing a simple order form instead of WooCommerce or a shopping cart plugin and wish to optimize that page as a product, you can do so with All in One SEO. Simply edit the page and in the AIOSEO settings, modify its schema type to Product.
!Product schema type for AIOSEO
Champion: All in One SEO
Yoast provides additional eCommerce support through an extension. However, All in One SEO simplifies the process and includes the capability to optimize product pages without the need to install an eCommerce plugin, making it more suitable for online stores.
Additional SEO Utilities – All in One SEO vs Yoast SEO
On-page SEO requires a thorough approach. That’s why both plugins offer supplementary tools and functionalities alongside meta tags.
These features are designed to offer you a complete solution and negate the necessity for installing multiple other SEO plugins.
Yoast SEO – Extra Tools
Yoast SEO arrives with a comprehensive setThe functionality of features that encompass most elements of on-site optimization is robust. Here are some tools provided:
- Breadcrumb Navigation
- Open Graph Meta Tags
- Data Import from Google Webmaster Tools
- Integrated robots.txt and .htaccess editor
- SEO data Import/Export
- Manager for Redirects
The Additional Tools in All in One SEO
All in One SEO presents a matching array of features with an enhanced user interface.
- Breadcrumbs Navigation
- Open Graph Meta Tags
- Robots.txt and .htaccess editor
- SEO Data Import and Export
- Redirects Manager
Moreover, All in One SEO furnishes extra functions like:
- Headline Analyzer
- ChatGPT AI Tools
- SEO Search Statistics
- Keyword Rank Tracking
- Author SEO
- 404 Error Tracking
- Custom User Roles for SEO
Victor: All in One SEO
While both plugins offer a comprehensive array of SEO utilities, All in One SEO surpasses with its sleeker interface and abundance of additional functionalities compared to the Yoast SEO plugin.
Pricing – Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO
For many users, pricing may play a crucial role. Both plugins provide basic free versions, but unlocking their complete potential necessitates opting for the premium option.
The paid versions of both plugins grant priority support and regular updates.
Let’s delve into the pricing of both contenders.
Yoast SEO Pricing
Acquiring a single-site license for Yoast SEO premium is $99, with costs escalating upon adding more sites. Each extension such as WooCommerce SEO, Local, News, and Video SEO comes with an additional fee of $79 per single site.
Alternatively, you can opt for their yearly subscription plan priced at $229, encompassing all extensions. However, it is restricted to a single website usage, necessitating additional subscriptions for each additional website.
All in One SEO Pricing
The free version of All in One SEO provides limited support and features.
For enhanced support, users can opt for a paid plan starting at $49.60 for a single site inclusive of one year of support and updates.
Opting for their best-value plan priced at $199.60 includes all add-ons and features for up to 10 sites.
Victor: All in One SEO
Regarding pricing, if you operate only one website, the costs are quite similar. However, all Yoast subscriptions are restricted to a single website, whereas All in One SEO’s Pro plan accommodates up to 10 websites, rendering it a superior choice.
For more in-depth insights, check out our comprehensive AIOSEO review.
Conclusion: Yoast SEO vs All in One SEO – Which Prevails?
Both Yoast SEO and All in One SEO stand as commendable plugins, making a close comparison between the two inevitable. However, All in One SEO emerges as the preferred choice in terms of simplicity, enhanced user experience, and greater control over diverse features.
All in One SEO also gains an edge in eCommerce SEO, offering schema support for eCommerce and local SEO. Additionally, its on-site SEO audit and TruSEO score features equip novices with an actionable roadmap to augment their content and elevate their SEO performance.
For users managing multiple websites, All in One SEO offers substantial cost savings.
For a more detailed analysis, refer to our article elucidating why we transitioned from Yoast to All in One SEO.
We trust that this comparison between Yoast SEO and All in One SEO has guided you in selecting the optimal WordPress SEO plugin for your website. You may also explore our roster of premier WordPress SEO extensions and tools, and peruse our guide on selecting the finest WordPress hosting providers.
If you found this article informative, consider subscribing to our YouTube Channel for an array of WordPress video tutorials. You can also stay connected with us on Twitter and Facebook.
EN 
ZH 
ZH_CN 
JA 
KO